Keane: Carrick Not the Right Choice for Permanent Man United Role Despite Improvement
Manchester United legend Roy Keane has praised the team’s recent resurgence but insists that Michael Carrick is not the right person to take over as the club’s permanent manager.
Speaking after United’s dramatic 3–2 win over Arsenal, Keane acknowledged the team’s improved performances but stressed that a couple of strong results do not make a case for giving Carrick the managerial job full-time. “Even if United win every game until the end of the season, I still wouldn’t give him the job,” he said, adding that the club needs a “bigger and better manager” with the experience to consistently win league titles and compete at the highest levels of European football.
Keane praised United’s display against Arsenal, highlighting the players’ composure under pressure, the quality of the goals, and the significant influence of substitutes who changed the course of the game. He noted that the performance showed real character and technical skill but warned that temporary success under Carrick is not enough to meet the expectations of a club of Manchester United’s stature.
The former midfielder argued that while Carrick has done well in his caretaker role, long-term leadership at a club like United requires proven managerial experience. He stressed that United’s ambitions are vast and that the team needs a manager who can build a winning culture, inspire the squad, and deliver consistency in both domestic and European competitions.
Keane also reflected on the progress of the players themselves, noting that their improved performances are encouraging and demonstrate the squad’s quality. However, he said that talent alone cannot sustain success without a manager capable of strategic planning and long-term vision.
In conclusion, Keane emphasized that Carrick’s current work is commendable but reiterated that Manchester United requires a permanent manager with the expertise and authority to restore the club to its former glory. The legend insisted that fans and players alike deserve leadership that combines tactical acumen, experience, and the ability to consistently challenge for trophies.
#UTVAfrica#
